So: It appears to be Valentine’s Day again. Whatever, it’s cool. I think people in relationships deserve to a have a day in which to throw their tenuous connection to another desperate human being into everybody’s faces, since they’re normally so discreet and timid about it the other 364 days a year.
I don’t really have a good Valentine’s Day story to share about my own past relationships. That’s partly out of respect for the other people involved, but mostly I can’t think of any in which I come off looking like anything other than a mediocre partner. I like a certain amount of distance in a relationship, and assume that others do as well: “I should call her–but wait, it’s only been two weeks. Jeez, give the girl some space.”
Instead, let’s talk about other people’s relationships.
One weekday, a few years ago, I went to an Italian restaurant for lunch. It was in a not-very-well-known wine-producing region, off the side of a road, surrounded by a picturesque stand of trees. It was an okay place.
As I sat there, waiting for my food, I started discretely checking out the other tables, and I slowly began to notice something. There was a distinct, but subtle, Twilight Zone vibe emerging. It was a growing sense of weirdness–the cause of which seemed to be just below a conscious level of awareness.
At the table nearest to me, there was a couple. They appeared to be married. The man was somewhere around fifty or so. He was tall, thin, and had a salt-and-pepper beard and hair thing going on. He had Caesar-style hair cut. The women he was with looked to be in either her mid-to-late thirties, or possibly early forties. Long, mousey brown hair. She was shorter than her date, with wide hips and glasses. I don’t think it’s too much of a jump to suggest that the first preset on their Mercedes’ stereo was an NPR station, but the most common sound in the vehicle was likely either jazz or a baseball game.
That’s not the weird part.
I was slowly beginning to realize where the peculiar sensation I was feeling was coming from. And then suddenly, it was as clear as glass. I took a good, hard, rude look at the table next to them. And there they were.
No, wait. There they were.
A near identical couple–as near enough as to make no difference. Another silver fox, another set of friendly, child-bearing hips. Another pair of glasses. Another brown cardigan. Another Mercedes with a child’s car seat in the back.
I rubbed my eyes. I took off my glasses and tried again.
What were the odds? I wondered. What where the odds that a couple and their doppelgangers would decide to visit the same restaurant, at the same time, on the same day? Pretty remote, I thought. And yet, it was so.
I turned my head to look at the table behind me, on some Fortean hunch. And there they were. Again.
Things went a bit swimmy, but I craned my neck around, finally taking it all in. In this small restaurant, on this strange day, I counted six virtually indistinguishably similar couples. If they all had to go to the bathroom at the same time, I wondered if any of them would end up back with the people with whom they’d arrived. To be fair, I’m sure they all had distinct personalities and varied outlooks on life, but if the ensuing conversation involved a discussion of someone named Madison’s progress in Gymboree, the swtich up might not have been noticed for a couple of hours at least.
In my heart, I know that the world is a teeming menagerie of unique and heterogeneous individuals–a vast array of diverse human beings representing every imaginable physical configuration. But no, not at this restaurant.
The thing I found so uncomfortable about the situation wasn’t the stark evidence of reality’s own copy/paste hackwork; nor was it the realization that, even though I am normally out of place in most places, I was especially so in this particular locale. It was the fact that all these similar people had to know that they were all currently drinking wine and eating brushcetta whilst surrounded by their own virtual clones.
Empathetic as I am, I could not get a bead on what they must have been feeling. Did they find it comforting to be with so many people who were so similar to themselves? Was it an assault on their sense of hard-won individuality? Were they too relaxed and centered to even notice? Being a rather neurotic sort of man myself, I had plenty of discomfort to go around, if they needed it.
I suspect that yes, they probably did notice. And I also suspect that, if they really cared to think about it at all, they probably found it harmlessly amusing. The easy, confident satisfaction they all seemed to radiate implied the kind of serenity that would remain unmarred by such inconsequential happenstances. They would all go home to their golden retrievers and leather couches, and probably not even remember the scene.
But I would remember. I would gnaw on my bread stick and my marginal, fringe existence, and remember. I would be comforted by the fact that the contentment that each of them had found was rare, but not unrepeatable.
Happy Valentine’s Day.