So, here’s something that’s been bothering me lately: The “Obscure Common Interests” fallacy. Broadly defined, it is the erroneous notion that two strangers should enter into a relationship with each other solely on the basis that they happen to both enjoy something that most other people do not.
Let me clarify this idea with an example: “Hey, you like comic books, too? We must be soulmates!” Granted, this is not something most people would say explicitly, but it is an internal thought that is not far removed from the rather dire overt expressions of interest that one often sees in some fan communities.
For, indeed, it is within fandoms that the Obscure Common Interest fallacy can be most easily found. It’s the obscurity thing. If you replace the words “comic books” in the above example with the word “tacos,” you’ll get what I mean. Everybody loves tacos, so much so that even the most imaginative relationship-seeker would be unable to bring themselves to suggest that a shared appreciation for them would be a viable basis for a personal connection.
But where obscurity reigns all bets are off.
The problem is that shared common interests are only a small part of what makes a relationship happen. It can certainly help, but some parts are more important than others–and knowing the stardates for each episode of TOS hardly rates. A vastly more important part is sheer physical attraction.
Like hell, you say? What kind of shallow, cynical, selfish world am I suggesting we live in, here? Well, relax–it’s not as bad as it sounds, okay? Now hold still while I gently shove this into your brain.
You can have a relationship based solely on mutual physical attraction (at least for a while). You can have a relationship based solely on greed for power or money (at least until the kids are able to get the will changed). You can even have a relationship based solely on mutual desperation (at least until something better comes along). But it is very, very unlikely that you will be able to forge a relationship based on a shared interest in Battlestar Galactica if the two of you can’t stand to look at each other naked.
It can of course be wonderful to have a relationship with some who shares your esoteric obsessions. But that can’t be the only thing; you can make friends out of fannishness, but there’s got to be other stuff in the mix if you’re talking romance. Stuff like sharing the same sense of humor, or other compatible personality traits.
And don’t forget: In general, in mundane life, most relationships grow out of a pair of people’s mutual desire to bone each other. The rules don’t change just because you’re in a hobby shop or at PAX. I mean, yes, people are turned on by a wide variety of things, but the number of people in the world who will respond to your casually rattled-off list of Dalek-operators with an enthusiastic cry of “Take me now, right here on this pile of anoraks!” is pretty low.
I’m not saying you’re ugly. Nobody’s saying that. There are lots of reasons that someone might not want to sleep you. People are weird. However, avoid the temptation to blame them for it. It is not their fault. Sleeping with somebody that you’re not attracted to is hell, and it is a basic human right that you don’t have to. You are a good enough person to respect that, even if it leaves you high and dry, okay?
If the realization that you are no more likely to meet the love of your life at a Star Trek convention than you are out in the normal world is getting you down, buck up little ensign. I said it’s not as bad as it sounds, and I meant it. Since shared obscure interests are off the list of sure-fire relationship fodder, the good news is that the person you will spend the rest of your life with doesn’t have to be someone who is also in to your fannish obsessions. This should be especially heartening for fans of Space:1999 and Sonic the Hedgehog cosplay, but it means a richer, more vibrant world for everybody. It does mean that you might have to put up with listening to endless monologues about America’s Got Talent or Eurovision or whatever, but we could all stand to be a bit more open-minded about these things anyway, right?
And another thing: knowing that mutual obscure interests do not much tilt the odds in your favor when flirting with someone should also help with knowing when to back the hell off.
I’m not just talking to fen, here, by the way. I’m also talking to those people out there who feel an overwhelming desire to force together any two people they know who just happen to both own Babylon 5 t-shirts. Hey! Much like this post, that sort of thing is reductive and condescending, okay? Quit it!